Vistage Research Center

Get actionable, data-driven insights and expert perspectives from our global community of CEOs and thought leaders. Led by Joe Galvin, Chief Research Officer

This is NOT the Marine Corps! In Business, It IS Okay to Leave Someone Behind


The United States Marines follow the motto of Semper Fidelis, Latin for “always faithful.”  One example of this intense loyalty is on the battlefield, where Marines will risk life and limb to rescue fallen soldiers, even dead ones, leaving no man behind.  However admirable on the battlefield, this sense of loyalty just doesn’t translate to the business world.

Today, too many managers are vested in those they hire, which makes it tough to terminate employees who aren’t working out.  Even when a manager is ready to terminate someone, HR rules and procedures make it difficult for Front Line Leaders to provide appropriate consequences for poor work performance.  As a result (using the Marine analogy), managers-like soldiers-spend their time and energy dragging dead weight around the office battlefield.  It’s time to stop hauling around those employees (The Others) who should have been fired yesterday.

So, who are The Others?  In most companies, employees fall into three groups.  Core Employees, comprising about 20 percent of the workforce, are dedicated to giving everything to do their jobs well.  They are intrinsically driven to put forth 100 percent effort. Temporary Employees—people who haven’t figured out yet whether they want to be a Core Employee or not—account for about 60 percent of the workforce. They give 50–80 percent effort. Some Temporary Employees eventually become one of The Others—the remaining 20 percent of the workforce—who have made a career out of mediocrity by doing just enough to not get fired but not nearly enough to help move your business forward.

It’s easy to identify The Others.  They are poor, average, or even good employees—but they aren’t great, and it’s clear that they don’t want to be. Not only do they underachieve, but their presence is also poison.  Temporary Employees see The Others getting by with minimal effort and can be influenced to join them.  It is also extremely demotivating for hard-working Core Employees to know The Others are still around. Yet managers hesitate to let them go, thinking it may reflect poorly on their own hiring decision. You can’t afford to keep even one employee who isn’t performing his best.

What should you do?  First, ensure that each employee has the understanding and resources necessary to complete the job. If the job isn’t completed, the employee must face clearly established consequences such as progressive discipline, which provides a limited opportunity to correct the problem satisfactorily.  If the correction doesn’t happen, the employee should be fired. Don’t be tempted to save The Others, as keeping them around drags down the entire team.

What does HR say about this?  Many HR rules were implemented to protect employees from harsh or unfair bosses and to protect the company from lawsuits.  In this Knowledge Economy, however, Front Line Leaders must have more latitude in making employment decisions because they shoulder the responsibility of team performance.  If managers establish performance expectations for all employees, monitor progress, promptly address problems, and document each step, they should be free to fire underperforming employees without recrimination from HR.

Some of The Others will always find their way into your company—either by mistake or because a Temporary Employee becomes one of them—so you can’t completely avoid them.  But you can continuously evaluate and prune.  Hold employees accountable—and when they don’t deliver, follow the procedures to get rid of them.

In the Marines, soldiers are so loyal to each other that they will go through fire (literally) to do their jobs.  It makes sense not to leave one behind!  In business, however, when The Others aren’t loyal enough to travel through fire with you, it is imperative that you leave them behind.

Featured Image Credit: https://www.flickr.com/photos/dvids/3543162960/

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
3 comments
  1. Sacramento carpet cleaners

    January 9, 2012 at 10:45 am

    I want to say that this post is amazing, great written and include approximately all important infos. I’d like to see extra posts like this.

    Reply
  2. S Washburn

    January 12, 2012 at 2:53 pm

    Interesting, but very true. In my last position, our unit had the worst reputation for sick calls. However, policy dictated that 3 sick calls were allowed in a 120 day period. 4th got you a “warning”, 5 th got you “last warning” I.e. one more sick call within 3 month period, “YOU’RE FIRED”! Also, it was a “no fault” policy. So, even though peers and management were aware that you were barfing your brains out due to your attendance at a concert the night before…we were unable to act upon that. Certainly, employees were smart enough to dance within or around the 120 day rule. A cycle that caused resentment, frustration and discontent among those who were “doing the right thing”.

    Reply
  3. Gus Bolanio

    March 12, 2013 at 10:48 am

    I agree with many of the comments made by Mr. Glover except for the Marine Corps comparison. “As a result (using the Marine analogy), managers-like soldiers-spend their time and energy dragging dead weight around the office battlefield. It’s time to stop hauling around those employees (The Others) who should have been fired yesterday.”
    The problem with Mr. Glover’s proposition is that it assumes that the “employees/Marines that are being dragged around” should have been fired yesterday. It implies that they were killed do to their incompetence.
    I beg to differ. Those Marines served to the best of their abilities and with full knowledge that their action in combat may result in death. They believed that if killed in combat, someone would bring their bodies back as Marines promise each other. Its part of your “employment benefit package.” If in the business world you promise a bonus for performace, as a leader you should keep your word. In the Marine Corps, the promise to bring you back is more than a bonus…it is a managerial honor and part of you integrity as a leader. Leave him behind, and no one else will follow you!!!
    Does the principle translate to business? Of course it does. You don’t leave valuable employees behind by continuously providing them training on new technology and industry trends. Is it more efficient to develop an experience successful employee or do you fire or leave him/her behind because his 1960s college education did not teach power-point?
    The Marine Corps motto works! It is a form of emotional intelligence by knowing yourself as well as the emotions of your men/women. The business world should learn from them.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Predefined Skins

Primary Color

Background Color

Example Patterns

demo demo demo demo demo demo demo demo demo demo

Privacy Policy Settings

  • Required Cookies
  • Performance Cookies
  • Functional Cookies
  • Advertising Cookies
These cookies are essential in order to enable you to move around the Sites and use its features, such as accessing secure areas of the Sites and using Vistage’s Services. Since these cookies are essential to operate Vistage’s Sites and Services, there is no option to opt out of these cookies.
These cookies collect information about how visitors our Sites, for instance which pages visitors go to most often. These cookies don’t collect information that identifies a visitor. All information these cookies collect is aggregated and therefore anonymous. If you do not allow these cookies we will not know when you have visited our site, and will not be able to monitor its performance.

Cookies used

Visual Web Optimizer
These cookies remember information you have entered or choices you make (e.g. as your username, language, or your region), and provide enhanced, more personal features. They may also be used to provide services you have asked for such as watching a video or commenting on a blog. They may be set by us or by third party providers whose services we have added to our pages. If you do not allow these cookies then some or all of these services may not function properly.

Cookies used

Google Analytics
GTM
Gravity Forms
These cookies are used to make advertising more relevant to you and your interests. The cookies are usually placed by third party advertising networks. They remember the websites you visit and that information is shared with other parties such as advertisers. If you do not allow these cookies, you will experience less targeted advertising.